Claire (Lindsey Shaw) forces Justin (Dan Byrd) to become the school’s mascot ‘Musky, the Fish’ but just the thought of performing makes Justin physically ill, so Raja (Adhir Kalyan) takes over the job and the crowd goes wild for his gravity-defying moves. When Raja’s enthusiasm leads to a confrontation with a spectator, Justin realizes he must face his fears and make Franny (Amy Pietz) proud.

Meanwhile, when a still-unemployed Gary (Scott Patterson) realizes he is not needed at home, he accidentally stumbles into a relationship with surrogate family who loves having him around.

Andy Frickman directed the episode written by Emily Kapnek